Shopify's CEO Just Called Out the $1.5 Billion Accessibility Lawsuit Industry. Here's What He Got Right—and What He Missed.

When the CEO of a platform powering 30% of US eCommerce speaks up about predatory lawsuits, the entire industry should listen. Yesterday, Tobias Lütke did exactly that.

As the founder and CEO of TestParty, I've seen firsthand how digital accessibility lawsuits have weaponized the Americans with Disabilities Act. We're on track to complete 10,000 automated and manual accessibility audits this year for companies generating over $2 billion in eCommerce revenue. And let me tell you: Lütke is absolutely right about the problem, but his solution misses the mark.

The Anatomy of a $1.5 Billion Shakedown

Let's start with the numbers that should make every business owner's blood boil.

In 2023 alone, 4,605 accessibility lawsuits were filed against American businesses. But that's just the tip of the iceberg. Here's what the real math looks like:

The Conservative Estimate:

• 4,605 lawsuits × $25,000 average cost = $115 million
• ~15,000 demand letters × $25,000 = $375 million
• Annual impact: $490+ million

The Reality Check: Industry insiders estimate over 250,000 demand letters are sent annually—most settling quietly to avoid public litigation. At $25,000 per settlement (including legal fees and remediation), we're looking at $6.25 billion extracted from American businesses each year.

Even if we split the difference, this is easily a $1.5+ billion industry built on what amounts to legal extortion.

The Predatory Playbook: How Serial Plaintiffs Game the System

The most damaging revelation from our data? This isn't about helping people with disabilities. It's about profit, pure and simple.

Consider these statistics:

• 80% of all ADA lawsuits come from "serial plaintiffs" who file at least 8 cases per year
• One New York law firm is responsible for 25% of all digital ADA lawsuits nationwide
• Just 31 plaintiffs and 16 firms drove 50% of all cases in the first half of 2025
• Average settlements range from $10,000 to $80,000 (based on TestParty's client data)

One particularly egregious example: A single plaintiff filed 113 lawsuits in 2024. Another law firm filed 2,598 federal ADA Title III lawsuits that same year. These aren't advocates for accessibility, they're profiteers exploiting a broken system.

Where Shopify Gets It Right

Lütke and his team deserve credit for several key insights:

1. Small Businesses Are Getting Crushed

The article correctly identifies that 73% of lawsuits target businesses with less than $25 million in revenue. These companies often lack dedicated legal teams or accessibility experts, making them easy marks for serial plaintiffs.

2. The Settlements Don't Improve Accessibility

As one business owner told Shopify: "I told them my site would be ADA compliant by a certain date. But I never heard from them once they got their check."

This is the dirty secret of accessibility litigation: The lawyers don't care if your site becomes accessible. They just want their settlement check so they can move on to the next victim.

3. It's Killing the American Dream

When small business owners have to choose between investing in growth or paying off predatory lawyers, innovation dies. One food and beverage founder described getting served papers on her birthday, then spending a year battling a lawsuit before settling. "It was the first thing I thought about when I woke up every morning," she said.

Where Shopify Gets It Wrong

But here's where I have to respectfully disagree with Lütke's analysis.

The "No Clear Guidelines" Myth

Shopify's article claims "there are no clear guidelines or specific steps" for accessibility compliance. This is technically incorrect and dangerously misleading.

The Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA provide extremely detailed, specific standards for digital accessibility. These guidelines cover everything from color contrast ratios to keyboard navigation requirements. They're internationally recognized and have been the de facto standard for over a decade.

The real problem isn't a lack of guidelines—it's that:

1. Implementation is complex and requires specialized expertise
2. Compliance is ongoing, not a one-time fix
3. Testing requires both automated and manual processes
4. Most small businesses can't afford dedicated accessibility teams

The Oversight on Overlays

While Shopify correctly identifies that the current system is broken, they don't address one of the biggest problems: accessibility overlays.

These "quick fix" widgets promise ADA compliance with a single line of code. In reality, they often make sites less accessible and have been explicitly cited in 25% of lawsuits as creating additional barriers. The FTC even fined leading overlay provider AccessiBe $1 million in 2025 for false advertising.

The Real Solution: Empowerment Through Technology and Education

At TestParty, we've taken a different approach. Instead of selling snake oil or waiting for legislation that may never come, we're building tools that actually solve the problem.

What Real Accessibility Compliance Looks Like

1. Comprehensive Auditing

• Automated scanning catches ~30% of issues
• Manual testing by certified professionals identifies the remaining 70%
• Real user testing with people who have disabilities

2. Code-Level Remediation

• Fix issues at the source, not with band-aid overlays
• Integration with development workflows (GitHub, CI/CD pipelines)
• Developer education to prevent future issues

3. Continuous Monitoring

• Weekly automated scans
• Quarterly manual audits
• Real-time alerts for new accessibility issues

4. Legal Protection Documentation

• Detailed compliance reports
• Historical testing records
• Proof of ongoing remediation efforts

Making Compliance Affordable

The reason 75% of eCommerce businesses remain vulnerable isn't ignorance—it's economics. Traditional accessibility consultants charge $50,000+ for a single audit. Most small businesses simply can't afford it.

That's why we've built TestParty to democratize accessibility compliance:

• Automated scanning starting at $99/month
• Hybrid audits (automated + manual) from $500/month
• Complete remediation packages that cost less than a single lawsuit settlement

The Path Forward: Notice and Cure Legislation

Shopify is right to advocate for "notice and cure" legislation. This reform would require plaintiffs to notify businesses of accessibility issues and provide 30-60 days to fix them before filing suit.

This simple change would:

• Eliminate drive-by lawsuits
• Give businesses a chance to improve accessibility
• Ensure money goes toward actual remediation, not lawyer fees
• Maintain legal protections for people with disabilities

Several states are already considering such legislation, and federal proposals are gaining traction in Congress.

The Bottom Line for Business Owners

If you're running an eCommerce business in 2025, here's what you need to know:

1. You're at risk regardless of size or location. If you sell online, you can be sued in New York or California
2. Overlays won't protect you—they might make you a bigger target
3. Waiting for perfect legislation is a losing strategy
4. Proactive compliance costs 10x less than reactive settlements

A Call to Action for the Industry

Shopify deserves enormous credit for using their platform to spotlight this issue. When a company powering 30% of US eCommerce speaks up, people listen.

But awareness isn't enough. We need:

• Industry collaboration on accessibility standards
• Technology solutions that make compliance achievable
• Legislative reform to eliminate predatory lawsuits
• Education to help businesses understand their obligations

As Lütke correctly noted: "True accessibility comes from collaboration and clear standards, not lawyers treating the ADA as a revenue stream."

The disability community deserves better than predatory lawyers claiming to represent their interests. Small businesses deserve better than shakedown lawsuits. And the internet deserves to be accessible to everyone.

At TestParty, we're committed to making that vision a reality—one accessible website at a time.

Michael is the Co-founder and CEO of TestParty, an AI-powered digital accessibility compliance platform. TestParty has completed over 10,000 accessibility audits for businesses generating $2+ billion in annual eCommerce revenue. Learn more at testparty.com or connect with Michael on LinkedIn.

Ready to protect your business from accessibility lawsuits? Get your free accessibility scan and see where you stand.