How We're Not Really Strangers Switched from accessiBe to Code-Level Shopify Accessibility Compliance in Weeks

We're Not Really Strangers is a purpose-driven card game and movement dedicated to empowering meaningful connections. Created by Koreen Odiney in 2018, the brand has grown from a viral social experiment into a cultural phenomenon, with millions of followers across social media and a thriving ecommerce business. As a small but mighty team focused on authentic human connection, ensuring their digital experience was truly accessible to all customers became a strategic priority that aligned with their core mission.

The Challenge: When Quick Fixes Don't Feel Right

For Kerry Drenan, Senior Ecommerce Manager at We're Not Really Strangers, accessibility initially emerged as part of a broader compliance response.

As a one-person ecommerce team without dedicated compliance resources or deep technical knowledge, accessiBe seemed like the logical quick solution. But the experience quickly revealed fundamental concerns:

The Widget Problem: Visible and Unclear

"The experience of having accessiBe on the website is a little clunky," Kerry recalls. "The little widget pop-up felt messy. We like a simple website, so it felt a little out of place."

For a brand built on authentic connection and thoughtful design, the visible accessibility widget created friction with their carefully crafted user experience. But the concern went deeper than aesthetics.

Lack of Transparency and Confidence

"It felt not as legit because it's just the widget. There's nothing on the back end," Kerry explains. "It felt like we don't even know what it's doing other than when you click through the features."

The accessiBe overlay provided no visibility into what was actually being fixed, no regular audits, and no way to verify that the solution was genuinely making the site accessible. For a team that valued authenticity, this lack of transparency was troubling.

Limited Team Bandwidth

With no compliance team, no developers, and a full roadmap of ecommerce initiatives, Kerry needed a solution that would work without requiring extensive internal resources or technical expertise. The widget offered coverage in theory, but provided no ongoing validation or meaningful reporting.

Why TestParty: Real Fixes with Complete Transparency

When evaluating accessibility overlay alternatives, several factors made TestParty's approach to Shopify accessibility stand out:

Code-Level Implementation Instead of Overlay Technology

Unlike accessibility overlay solutions like accessiBe, UserWay, or AudioEye, TestParty implements fixes directly in the Shopify theme code. This approach provides transparent, permanent accessibility improvements that can be reviewed and verified—not hidden behind a widget.

Ongoing Audits Replace Invisible Monitoring

"The monthly … audits that you guys provide are really awesome," Kerry notes. "The widget is just kind of there, and then no one on the accessiBe team is checking or sending over frequent audits like that."

TestParty's accessibility testing and remediation platform provides regular WCAG compliance audits with clear, comprehensive reporting. Every scan surfaces new issues, tracks remediation progress, and provides a detailed audit log of what changed and why—something completely missing from the overlay widget experience.

SEO Benefits Through Comprehensive Alt Text

An unexpected value driver emerged early in the evaluation: "The alt text feature and the SEO side of it was really interesting. Just knowing that's a feature and that also can improve performance aspects of the website."

For a small team managing multiple priorities, TestParty's automated alt text implementation provided dual benefits: accessibility compliance and search engine optimization. This strategic value positioned accessibility as more than just risk mitigation.

No Visible Widget for Customers

"The customer can't see the widget—that widget just bothers us so much and it just feels kind of silly," Kerry emphasizes. "It feels like a legit solution for our website."

Removing the visible accessibility overlay restored the clean, intentional user experience the brand had carefully designed.

The Implementation: Faster and Easier Than Expected

One of Kerry's primary concerns was the internal lift required from an already-stretched one-person team. The reality exceeded expectations:

Minimal Internal Resources Required

"It was super easy to install. It went quicker than I thought," Kerry recalls. "I feel like there really wasn't a lift on my side other than just reviewing the new theme."

TestParty's process involved:

• Requesting Shopify collaborator access
• Duplicating the live theme for testing
• Implementing all accessibility fixes in the duplicate
• Delivering changes for review via Shopify's native interface

No GitHub knowledge required. No developer resources needed. Just straightforward theme review and approval.

Weeks to Comprehensive Compliance

"We went live in what, like a few weeks or so from onboarding? That was really cool. Just felt like a breeze and not complicated at all from my side."

For Shopify stores concerned about accessibility audit timelines and implementation complexity, TestParty's approach demonstrates how accessibility remediation automation can accelerate deployment without requiring technical expertise.

Complete Visibility Into Changes

Unlike the accessiBe widget that operated as a black box, TestParty provided complete transparency. Kerry could review every fix in the Shopify duplicate theme before it went live, understand exactly what changed, and maintain full control over her store's codebase.

The TestParty dashboard showed:

• All issues found on each page
• Specific locations of accessibility violations
• Actions taken to fix each issue
• Before and after states
• Third-party app issues identified

The Results: Peace of Mind and Strategic Value

Compliance Without the Visual Clutter

The team gained comprehensive Shopify ADA compliance without the visible widget that had disrupted their carefully designed user experience. The accessibility improvements now lived in the code where they belonged—invisible to customers but making the site genuinely accessible.

Accessibility as Measurable Strategy

Moving beyond basic compliance, Kerry sees broader strategic value: "Usually I feel like in the past, compliance was just set there and it's not really doing anything for us other than keeping us compliant. It'll be cool to see how the SEO impacts the performance side."

The shift from reactive compliance to proactive optimization represents a fundamental change in how the brand approaches digital accessibility. With quarterly audits providing regular reporting, accessibility became a measurable part of their digital strategy rather than an invisible widget they hoped was working.

Looking Forward: Real Solutions Over Band-Aids

When asked what advice she'd give to other organizations considering similar accessibility solutions, Kerry emphasizes learning from her own journey:

Don't Rush to Band-Aid Solutions

"Definitely focus on not rushing into just a band-aid solution, like a widget or anything, but really doing your own research even if you don't have a big team or big compliance team."

Prioritize Before Problems Escalate

"Even if you think you're safe with the policies and stuff, just making sure you have actual solutions in place that protect you and your website. Because it does happen and there are lawsuits. It can be really costly once those lawsuits come through."

Look for Comprehensive, Transparent Solutions

"Make sure you have a full solution that's not just a band-aid pop-up widget solution and really doing your research when you can."

Kerry's advice reflects a growing understanding across the ecommerce industry: accessibility overlays may seem convenient, but they can't replace genuine code-level fixes that make sites truly accessible.

---

Ready to move beyond accessibility overlays to transparent, code-level Shopify accessibility compliance?

Visit TestParty to learn how our approach provides better protection and strategic value compared to accessiBe alternatives, or schedule a demo to see how TestParty can help your Shopify store achieve comprehensive WCAG compliance faster and more transparently than traditional accessibility overlay solutions.

Book a demo today: https://testparty.ai/book-a-demo