TestParty

Blog

The Complete Guide to Shopify Digital Accessibility: What Every E-Commerce Store Owner Must Know in 2025

TestParty
TestParty
November 20, 2025

With 4,605 ADA website lawsuits filed in 2024 and the European Accessibility Act enforcement starting June 28, 2025, Shopify store accessibility isn't optional—it's a business imperative. Here's what you need to know and do right now.

The $2.6 Trillion Reality Check

Picture this: A Shopify merchant invests $400 in a premium theme. Six months later, they're hit with an ADA lawsuit. The settlement? $10,000. The cost to fix their store? Another $40,000. This isn't a horror story—it's a common scenario for Shopify merchants who assumed their platform had accessibility covered.

The numbers tell a sobering story. Most Shopify stores fall short of WCAG 2.2 compliance despite Shopify's commitment to accessibility, creating significant legal risks while missing out on the $13 trillion disability market. In 2024 alone, 77% of digital accessibility lawsuits targeted e-commerce sites, with Shopify stores regularly appearing in court filings.

But here's what most merchants don't realize: The disability community represents 1.3 billion people globally with $2.6 trillion in disposable income. When you make your Shopify store accessible, you're not just avoiding lawsuits—you're opening doors to a massive, underserved market.

Why Shopify's Built-In Features Aren't Enough

Let's address the elephant in the room: Shopify provides an accessible foundation, but their requirements only cover 16-22% of WCAG success criteria. While Shopify has made significant investments in accessibility, particularly in their default themes like Dawn and their checkout process, the reality is more complex.

What Shopify Actually Provides:

  • Basic keyboard navigation support
  • ARIA labels in some themes
  • Semantic HTML structure in first-party themes
  • Alt text functionality for product images
  • Some accessibility features in checkout

What Shopify Doesn't Handle:

  • Third-party app accessibility
  • Custom theme modifications
  • Dynamic content accessibility
  • Complete WCAG 2.2 AA compliance
  • Content-specific accessibility issues

As one accessibility expert notes, automated testing tools can catch between 30-50% of errors, yet Shopify's requirements fall short of even this baseline. This gap leaves merchants vulnerable, especially when 722 ADA lawsuits in 2024 were filed against websites with accessibility widgets installed.

The Legal Landscape: What's At Stake

United States: The ADA Minefield

The Americans with Disabilities Act wasn't written with websites in mind—it's from 1990. Yet courts have consistently ruled that websites must be accessible. In the first half of 2025 alone, 2,014 ADA website accessibility lawsuits were filed—a 37% jump from 2024.

Key lawsuit trends:

Europe: The EAA Deadline

From June 28, 2025, the European Accessibility Act requires all digital products and services sold in the EU to be accessible to people with disabilities. This applies to any business selling in the EU, regardless of location.

Critical EAA requirements:

The 15 Most Common Shopify Accessibility Issues

Based on lawsuit data and WCAG requirements from Shopify's own documentation, here are the critical issues that appear in most complaints:

1. Missing or Poor Alt Text

Product images without descriptive alternative text are the #1 issue in lawsuits. Every image needs meaningful alt text that describes its content and purpose.

2. Insufficient Color Contrast

Body text needs a 4.5:1 contrast ratio against backgrounds, while headings (24px+) need at least 3:1. Many Shopify themes fail this by default.

3. Keyboard Navigation Failures

Every interactive element must be accessible via keyboard. This includes product selectors, cart functions, and checkout processes.

4. Form Field Problems

Unlabeled form fields, unclear error messages, and missing field instructions create barriers for screen reader users.

5. Auto-Playing Content

Slideshows and videos that play automatically can cause issues for users with vestibular disorders and interfere with screen readers.

6. Missing Focus Indicators

Users navigating with keyboards need visual indicators showing where they are on the page.

7. Improper Heading Structure

Headings must be used in sequential order (H1-H6) without skipping levels.

8. Inaccessible Third-Party Apps

Review widgets, chat functions, and payment processors often introduce accessibility barriers.

9. Touch Target Size

Mobile buttons and links need adequate spacing and size for users with motor impairments.

10. Missing Skip Links

Users should be able to skip repetitive navigation to reach main content quickly.

11. Justified Text Alignment

Justified text creates inconsistent spacing that's difficult for users with dyslexia.

12. Links Without Context

"Click here" or "Read more" links don't provide enough context for screen reader users.

13. Missing Language Attributes

Screen readers need proper language tags to pronounce content correctly.

14. Dynamic Content Issues

Cart updates, product filters, and AJAX-loaded content often fail to announce changes to screen readers.

15. PDF and Document Accessibility

Downloadable size guides, care instructions, and return policies must also be accessible.

The Overlay Trap: Why Quick Fixes Fail

When facing accessibility threats, many merchants reach for overlay widgets promising instant compliance for $20-50/month. Here's why that's dangerous:

The FTC reached a $1 million settlement with a major overlay provider for false advertising about their accessibility claims. Court documents reveal the harsh reality—in the Eyebobs case, the complaint explicitly stated that despite using an overlay, it failed to provide screen reader users full and equal access.

The statistics are damning:

  • 258 websites using overlays were sued in 2024
  • Overlays are now cited in 25% of lawsuits as creating additional barriers
  • Courts view overlays as evidence of inadequate remediation

Your Shopify Accessibility Action Plan with TestParty

Why TestParty is Different

TestParty focuses on correcting underlying accessibility errors within the source code rather than applying superficial overlays. As reported by Harlem Capital, TestParty creates a third space of "automated digital accessibility testing and remediation" that's significantly cheaper and faster than manual consultancies.

Key TestParty advantages:

Phase 1: Immediate Assessment with TestParty (Day 1)

  1. Deploy TestParty's AI-Powered Scanner
  2. Automatic Code Remediation
  3. Document Accessibility

Phase 2: Integration & Training (Week 1)

  1. Developer Integration
  2. Team Training
  3. Shopify-Specific Optimization

Phase 3: Ongoing Compliance (Continuous)

  1. Automated Monitoring
  2. Compliance Documentation
  3. Scale Across Properties

The ROI of Accessibility with TestParty

Immediate Cost Savings

Proactive compliance costs 10x less than reactive settlements. TestParty customers report:

SEO Benefits

Accessibility improvements directly boost SEO—proper heading structure helps search engines understand content, alt text provides additional indexable content, and improved navigation solves crawlability problems.

Market Expansion

As one customer testimonial states: "TestParty didn't just help us achieve compliance—they helped us build a better, more inclusive user experience by addressing root issues rather than applying quick fixes."

Preparing for the Future with TestParty

2025 Compliance Checklist

  • Deploy TestParty's scanner for immediate assessment
  • Fix all Level A violations with automated remediation
  • Address Level AA issues before June 2025 EAA deadline
  • Set up continuous monitoring and reporting
  • Train team using TestParty's integrated learning tools
  • Document all compliance efforts for legal protection

Beyond Compliance

TestParty sees an opportunity to expand beyond accessibility to automatically rewrite compliance code for SOC2, PII, HIPAA, and more. As CEO Michael Bervell explains: "No more audits or audit reports for code: just automated suggestions and code fixes within engineering codebases. Accessibility is just the beginning."

The Bottom Line

With lawsuits increasing 37% year-over-year and the EAA deadline approaching, the question isn't whether to make your Shopify store accessible—it's how quickly you can do it. TestParty's AI-powered platform offers the fastest, most cost-effective path to compliance.

Remember: The settlement money from lawsuits doesn't go toward improving access—it only enriches a single plaintiff and their lawyer. By investing in real accessibility with TestParty now, you're not just avoiding lawsuits; you're building a better, more profitable business that serves everyone.

Take Action Today with TestParty

Digital accessibility isn't a one-time fix—it's an ongoing commitment. TestParty makes that commitment manageable with:

  • Automated testing and remediation
  • Source code fixes, not overlays
  • Continuous compliance monitoring
  • Integration with your existing workflow

As TestParty's founders note: "It makes accessibility a human right, more affordable, in turn leading to the creation of a more accessible internet."

The disability community has waited long enough for equal access to digital commerce. The legal system is catching up. The market opportunity is massive. And with TestParty, the technology exists to make it happen efficiently and effectively.

Ready to protect your Shopify store and expand your market? Learn more about TestParty's automated accessibility platform and see how you can achieve WCAG 2.2 AA compliance in weeks, not months.

Sources:

Contact Us

Automate the software work for accessibility compliance, end-to-end.

Empowering businesses with seamless digital accessibility solutions—simple, inclusive, effective.

Book a Demo